Tuesday, November 17, 2026 Independent journalism
MediaChannel

bussiness

What is an earnout and how does it work in a business sale?

An earnout is a deal structure where part of the purchase price is paid after the sale closes, tied to how the business performs. It bridges valuation gaps, but the conditions matter enormously.

Business agreement with a handshake over contract documents at a meeting table.

Photo by Ron Lach on Pexels

An earnout is a contractual arrangement where a portion of the price paid for a business depends on what the business achieves after the sale closes. The buyer pays an agreed sum up front, then pays additional amounts if the acquired business hits specific revenue, profit, or operational targets over a defined period. Earnouts are common in acquisitions where the buyer and seller can't agree on what the business is actually worth today.

Why earnouts exist

Valuation gaps kill deals. A seller believes their business is worth $10 million because revenue is growing fast. The buyer thinks $7 million is fair because that growth hasn't been proven over time. Rather than walk away, both sides agree to split the difference through an earnout: $7 million now, with up to $3 million more if revenue hits the agreed benchmarks over the next two years.

This structure shows up most often in sectors where value is tied to intangibles: a software company whose product hasn't yet fully penetrated its market, a professional services firm where client relationships sit with the founder, or a startup that projects strong growth but doesn't yet have the numbers to back it up. Understanding how a business valuation works helps sellers see exactly where the gap tends to open up and why buyers reach for an earnout to manage it.

How the structure is set up

Every earnout has four essential components. First, the metric: what will be measured. Revenue is simplest but easiest to manipulate. EBITDA is harder to game but more sensitive to accounting choices. Some earnouts use customer retention rates, unit volumes, or clinical milestones for pharmaceutical deals. The choice of metric shapes every other decision in the structure.

Second, the target: the specific number the business must hit. Third, the period: how long the earnout runs. Most run between one and three years, though some stretch to five. Fourth, the payment formula: whether the earnout pays out in a lump sum on hitting the target, or on a sliding scale based on how close performance comes to the benchmark.

The legal documentation tying these together is detailed and consequential. It sits inside the broader sale agreement, which is why a solid due diligence process before signing matters so much. Sellers who skip careful legal review often find that the earnout terms they thought were clear become disputed the moment they're under a new owner's management.

The seller's core risk: loss of control

Once the sale closes, the seller no longer runs the business. The buyer does. That's the earnout's sharpest edge. A seller might be entitled to $3 million if the business hits $15 million in revenue over two years. But the buyer now controls hiring decisions, marketing spend, pricing, and product strategy. If the buyer decides to harvest margins rather than chase growth, revenue stalls and the earnout goes unpaid.

This isn't necessarily fraud. It's a conflict of interest baked into the structure. Buyers who paid a lower upfront price have less incentive to maximise performance during the earnout period. Sellers should negotiate specific protections: a commitment to maintain a minimum marketing budget, restrictions on asset sales or restructuring during the earnout window, and clear reporting obligations so the seller can verify the numbers independently.

What buyers watch out for

Buyers face the opposite problem. If the earnout metric is revenue, a departing founder might push short-term sales contracts that damage long-term margins. They might delay necessary costs to inflate short-term EBITDA. Some sellers fight to retain operational influence during the earnout period specifically to steer the numbers in their favour.

Buyers typically address this by choosing metrics that are harder to inflate in isolation, capping the seller's post-close involvement in sales decisions, or structuring the earnout around profit rather than revenue. Neither side is fully protected. A well-drafted earnout is a compromise between competing incentives, not a perfect solution.

Tax treatment in Australia

The Australian Taxation Office treats earnout payments differently depending on how the deal is structured. Under the look-through earnout rules introduced in 2016, most earnout payments relating to the sale of active assets are treated as part of the capital proceeds from the original sale rather than as separate income. This matters enormously for capital gains tax calculations. Sellers who qualify for the small business CGT concessions need to confirm that the earnout structure doesn't disqualify them from those concessions before the deal is signed.

The ATO's guidance on earnouts is specific enough that most advisers recommend getting a private binding ruling before finalising a deal with significant earnout components. This isn't optional caution. It's the difference between a tax outcome you planned for and one that arrives as a surprise two years after the sale.

When earnouts work and when they don't

Earnouts work best when the seller stays genuinely involved in the business post-close, the earnout period is short, the metric is objective and hard to manipulate, and the buyer has a strong incentive to grow rather than harvest. They fail most often when the seller has no post-close role, the earnout stretches beyond three years, or the relationship between buyer and seller turns adversarial before the period ends.

They also fail when the earnout makes up too large a share of the total price. If $7 million is paid up front and $6 million depends on the earnout, the seller has effectively financed the acquisition. That changes the risk profile entirely and should be reflected in the upfront terms. Sellers who understand how equity financing works will recognise the parallel: accepting deferred consideration is a form of seller financing, with all the exposure that carries.

Used well, an earnout closes deals that would otherwise collapse. Used carelessly, it transfers risk entirely onto the seller while locking in a buyer's right to pay less. The difference almost always comes down to how precisely the conditions are written before anyone signs.